What do former NBA star Michael Jordan, Rush Limbaugh, Sidney Frank, and the Tobacconist of Greenwich have in common: they have all laid hands on Marvin’s Mystery Box, the limited edition Elie Bleu humidor. This coveted humidor brought in over $1.8 million at a charity event in 2005 when it sold as a triple lot of humidors to Jordan, Limbaugh, and Frank. Now, the very humidor purchased by Sidney Frank that record-breaking night in April is currently at the Tobacconist of Greenwich, awaiting auction.
The legendary humidor already enjoyed the unofficial title of crowning jewel of the annual Night to Remember charity auction, hosted at the Four Seasons restaurant. Held for over 20 years now, Night to Remember is hosted by the editor and publisher of Cigar Aficionado magazine Marvin Shanken, with all proceed going to the Prostate Cancer Foundation.
Marvin’s Mystery Box was the capstone of Night’s auction in 2005, brought out after 18 other items were featured; items that included a collection of 693 Fuente-made cigars that included every Fuente Fuente Opus X, a trip for 10 on 141-foot luxury yacht in the Caribbean, and a chest filled with 100 bottles of rare wine. Yet even amidst this stunning lineup, Marvin’s Mystery box was held until the very end as befitting its station, after the Paradis Cognac was poured and the dinner cigars were lit.
The cedar-lined sycamore humidor, trimmed in ebony and inlayed with yellow sycamore is filled with unknown treasures and adorned with genuine Cuban cigar bands. It stands as the only non-cigar object that the Cuban government has allowed to be decorated in such a way. While the contents of the Mystery Box have never been divulged, it has been strongly hinted that it contains a trove of genuine Havanas.
The bidding started that night at a reasonable $50,000 and was headed toward a respectable mid $100,000 sale in Sidney Frank’s favor until Michael Jordan intervened. Well known for his appreciation of high-end cigars, Jordan and his tablemate, Rush Limbaugh, soon drove the price to the high $200,000’s as they played off each other in a three way bidding war. Shanken, recognizing the historic implications of the auction when the bidding hit $270,000, offered the trio a deal: he would triple the lot if each man agreed to pay $300,000 for a box. The total amount was then doubled by financer and cancer survivor Michal Milken, bringing the total sale to $1.8 million.
Now, the chance to walk the same historic paths as the men who inspired greatness in spirits, sports and politics is at hand. The bidding for Marvin’s Mystery Box will take place at a date to be announced in 2022, with an opening bid of $300,000. Interested parties should go to our auction below. Sign up for our newsletter to receive information about this auction.
Link to article detailing the historic auction can be found here.
Brick-and-mortar retailers are the backbone of the premium cigar industry, and for manufacturers like Davidoff, they are the company’s ambassadors and a connection to the end consumers. When it comes to finding a home for its premium cigars, Davidoff doesn’t look for just any retail outlet. It searches for true partners that will represent the heritage and traditions established by the company’s founder, Zino Davidoff, who opened his first cigar store in Geneva, Switzerland, in 1911. Zino Davidoff provided his customers with an exceptional experience, and he worked hard to establish strong ties with them—two characteristics that Davidoff continues to seek out from the company’s retail partners today.
“We look for retailers who will become long-term partners and local ambassadors of our global brands,” says Dylan Austin, president of Davidoff of Geneva Americas. “To gain consideration, we look for commitment and steady growth of our other core brands, enthusiasm and support of our programs, and obviously the quality of their retail environment. We also look for partners that share similar values and business priorities that align with the Davidoff standard of excellence. [Davidoff] Appointed Merchants must understand the importance of premium positioning, price protection, merchandising, training and education, and embrace our programs that focus on sales out to the consumer. They must share the same passion we have for Davidoff and in joining the global family of appointed merchants.”
“Oettinger Davidoff AG is a family-owned business which strongly believes in the values of trusted partnership, mutual respect and passion for our beautiful Davidoff brand and our customers,” adds Eddie Simon, chief marketing officer at Oettinger Davidoff. “These same values were lived by Zino Davidoff and still today are the foundation of choosing whom we welcome to the global Davidoff family of appointed merchants. It is this sense of commitment, dedication, and long-term development of business and brand that makes us grateful for the partners we do business with.”
In order to highlight those exceptional retailers that meet or exceed Davidoff’s high standard of excellence, the company launched its Davidoff Appointed Merchant program in the U.S. in 1990. In the beginning, there were only 24 Davidoff Appointed Merchants throughout the company, but 30 years later, that number has expanded to 290. Davidoff honors the program’s long history and puts a lot of time and consideration into selecting the right partners to join its prestigious program. It is careful not to dilute the market by adding too many appointed merchants, and less than 10 percent of Davidoff’s entire network of retailers have earned the Davidoff Appointed Merchant distinction.
Tobacco Business magazine caught up with three of Davidoff’s appointed merchant partners to discuss the benefits of being among Davidoff’s elite retailer partners and to talk about the company’s programs and benefits, as well as the way their business relationships with Davidoff have evolved over time. Those interviewed include Corey Johnston of Blend Bar with Davidoff Cigars, Michael Tortorea from Maxamar Ultimate Cigars and Michael Cafagno of Tobacconist of Greenwich. In addition to being part of the Davidoff Appointed Merchant program, each of these retailers has also been the recipient of multiple Golden Band Awards, an annual awards program that recognizes Davidoff’s top retail partners.
Tobacco Business: Davidoff’s heritage began in 1911 when Zino Davidoff opened his first cigar store in Geneva, Switzerland, because he had a love for cigars and providing an exceptional customer experience. What inspired you to become a part of the premium cigar business and to establish your own retail business? Corey Johnston: First, we liked the culture—the lifestyle is all-encompassing. Golfing, boating, fishing, hunting, fine wine and spirits, and cooking can all be enjoyed with cigars and friends. Second was the entertainment factor. There are not many upscale places in the U.S. with rare bourbon and single malts, fine wines and where people have the ability to also enjoy a cigar. So, the opportunity to start a new market made itself attractive.
Michael Tortorea: In my youth, I discovered a passion for great cigars by watching my father and his friends discuss world events and philosophy while enjoying cigars. As I grew older, I wanted to create that same atmosphere in our retail establishment. Since the inception of the brand, Zino made sure to exemplify what client service means and should be. That transcends us, and our customers expect top service, which is part of our genes.
Michael Cafagno: I came in here [Tobacconist of Greenwich] as a 19-year-old kid and as a customer. At the time, I was working three jobs—as a waiter, a laborer and a construction yarder. A friend of mine, who was a chef at the country club that I worked at, was a cigar smoker. I used to go to a shop in Yonkers [New York] that was like a newspaper store. I told him, “You’ve got to come with me and check this place out.” I brought him there, and he said to me, “Michael, this is not a cigar store; it’s a newspaper stand. I’m going to bring you to a real cigar shop.” I came here with him, and I walked into this kind of euphoric, beautiful tobacco store that I didn’t know existed. It was in a very old-world setting that was filled with dark woods and beautiful displays and kind of old-school methodology.
Hendrik “Henke” Kelner and Michael Cafagno
The owner of the store, Jimmy Lacerra, was a very well-dressed, polished man, and as soon as I walked in it was an intimidating sight as he was holding court with a bunch of guys. I walked in as this 19-year-old kid in jeans and a T-shirt while they were all dressed in suits, dress shirts and ties. When I walked in, Jimmy goes, “What do you want?” And I said, “I’d like to buy some cigars.” Now, at the time, I was making about $500 a week. He says, “You want to buy some cigars? You old enough?” I said, “Yeah, sure.” He responds, “Let me see your ID.” So, I show my ID. And he says, “All right, come on over here,” and he brings me over to the case and says, “How much money do you want to spend?” So, I figured, let me pretend like I have money so I don’t embarrass myself more than I already have. So, I said, “It makes no difference to me.” So, he starts picking out all these cigars—they were all Davidoff cigars. He brings me up to the register, and the total is $460. So, I’m saying to myself, “How am I going to pay for cigars? I don’t even know what they are.” I pay him, because I would have been embarrassed at the time if I didn’t. He kind of winked at me and said, “You come back here in a couple of weeks, kid, and I’ll teach you what you smoked.”
So, about six months after I started coming here, he asked, “Do you want to start working here on Saturday?” I said that I’d love to do that. At the time, I was still working three jobs and going to school full time, so my schedule was pretty packed. But I knew there was something about this place that I wanted to be a part of. I started working here full time as I was finishing up a college degree in forensic psychology. I had no idea what I wanted to do. I just knew I loved this place, and I loved Jimmy as a man, as a mentor and as somebody I looked up to. Later, I asked him [if I could] work there full time, which he said OK to, and he started teaching me about the business more—how to balance a checkbook, how to place orders, how to anticipate sales and how to treat people when they came in. When he passed, my relationships with the vendors at the store had become very solid, and everybody kind of rallied around the unspoken plan of allowing me to take the helm of this place and really make it grow and prosper.
The Davidoff Appointed Merchant program is available to just a few retailers across the globe that embody the drive and passion that Davidoff stands for. What does it mean to you for your store to be a Davidoff Appointed Merchant? Cafagno: What does it mean to me? That you’re the best in the business. The personal relationship that I have with all of their team is just something that you don’t find in this business. Your typical salesperson walks in and they want to sell you a service—that’s their only goal. It’s not to learn about your business; it’s not to know about you as a man or to learn about your consumers—it’s only to sell you cigars. With Davidoff, sure, the goal in the end is to sell a lot of cigars together, but the foundation of your relationship is so much more important to them. It’s about the type of retailer you are and the type of person you are. More importantly, that’s what your relationship is, and that’s how my relationship with them has formed—where I feel like if I sold my store tomorrow, that I’d still talk to every single one of them. So I would say that I can’t say enough good things about Davidoff as a company and how much I appreciate being a part of their team.
Tortorea: We belong to the family of Davidoff. The leadership and the embrace they provide is unmatched. We get access to some of the best cigars ever made, and we became a destination for Davidoff cigars’ clients.
Johnston: If you really want to be in the cigar business long term, not as a part-time hobby, then as a business owner you need to build a plan, execute the plan and eventually earn the opportunity to be a Davidoff Appointed Merchant. The best cigar industry retailers are Davidoff Appointed Merchants. Luxury brands like Rolex, Rolls Royce and Wilson Combat all formed partnerships with the best in the market.
Kim Arbuckle, Corey Johnston and Mark Holden own Blend Bar with Davidoff Cigars in Indianapolis, Indiana; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania; Nashville, Tennesse, and The Woodlands, Texas.
What ideas or characteristics do you embody that makes you stand apart from other retailers in the industry? Johnston: Attention to detail in everything that we do. Blend is a destination for those connoisseurs who want the best: cigars, bourbons, wine and VIP service. We start with a custom fresh-air replacement system in all of our stores. This one-of-a-kind HVAC is a costly expense; however, it creates an indoor environment that every guest appreciates. The level of guest service at Blend is unlike most retailers. The well-experienced staff offers walk-in humidor service, tableside cut and light, spirit pairing suggestions and attentive butler-style service.
Tortorea: Passion is crucial to success. At Davidoff, everyone is passionate about the product. We see it at the farms, the factory and at the corporate level. That inspires us retailers to treat the brand with care and loyalty to the level that our clients feel it. We always felt that our friends who share our philosophy and values would also make great ambassadors of cigars for our business.
Cafagno: I think honor is the most important thing in business. I’ve always been the kind of person that if I shake your hand and tell you I’m going to do something, I do it—and Davidoff has that quality about them as well. So that’s certainly a rarefied quality in today’s day and age. Now it’s kind of a dog-eat-dog world, and if someone’s got to screw you to get ahead, they do it. I don’t believe in that. I don’t believe in taking advantage of the weak. I believe in working as hard as you can to be the best that you can always be. That as a common value is shared between Davidoff and myself.
Davidoff values its indispensable business partner relationships with its customers. How have Davidoff programs helped you to grow your business? Cafagno: I would say the shop-in-shop is the No. 1 tool at our disposal
in terms of presence. Right when a customer walks into the store you have this big, beautiful white case that exudes luxury and attention. It is the first thing my guys look toward after they walk into my store. It’s not, “What do you have?” it’s, “Oh, that’s a cool case,” and they walk right over to it. Whether it’s subconsciously or consciously, that’s what they’re drawn to.
I would also say that their Viaje al Origen trips are a huge piece of their tools that they offer retailers. It was one of the most educational, incredible trips I’ve taken in my life. I learned more about my business in three days than I had in 10 years. The amount of knowledge that Klaas and Henke Kelner, Eladio Diaz, Hamlet Espinal and all these guys down in the Dominican [Republic] have—it’s the most sophisticated, simple operation I’ve ever seen in my life. There are no machines; it’s all hands. It’s all people that genuinely love doing what they’re doing, and they’re all happy. It’s a pretty amazing piece of the puzzle. When you go on that trip, you basically come out of it with a completely different understanding and appreciation for cigars, the science behind them, and how these guys are so good. That trip is an amazing asset that Davidoff has made available to retailers that I’d recommend every retailer should take because it is amazing what you’ll learn.
Johnston: The integrity of the Davidoff brand drives our profits. The quality of Davidoff cigars and Davidoff’s control of distribution secures our business sales cycles.
Ammar Tabbaa, owner of Maxamar Ultimate Cigars, accepting the Appointed Merchant award at the Golden Band Awards ceremony in 2013. Eliseo Gonzalez, a sales manager for Davidoff, is in the background.
Tortorea: Davidoff programs help tremendously through online courses. This makes us understand the products and be better at transferring the knowledge to our clients. Our local representative is very instrumental in the success of the programs, and he is excellent at his job.
The Golden Band Awards recognize the best of the best. You have won a Golden Band Award in the past. What did it mean to you and your business? Johnston: The Golden Band Awards are on display in the stores. It is always satisfying to be recognized, especially with other impressive [Davidoff] Appointed Merchants being nominated. The Golden Band Awards also inspire our staff to perform luxury service daily.
Cafagno: I’ve won five of them, and the Appointed Merchant of the Year is obviously the big one. Not that I need to be patted on the head or anything like that, but it was basically Davidoff saying, “Hey, man. Good job. Keep working.” It definitely was a nice thing that I respected, and I appreciate it. And it certainly gave me exposure. Being able to have that recognition from Davidoff also validates people’s opinions of this store, and you have something to say. It’s not just me saying, “I’ve got the best stuff here. Come buy cigars from Greenwich, Connecticut.” There’s truth to it. The Golden Band Awards have certainly validated that what I’m doing is real and genuine, and that it’s not something that I’m doing just to make money. I truly love what I do.
Tortorea: The Golden Band Awards are a great honor that every Davidoff dealer strives to achieve. It does help with sales because it inspires trust among Davidoff’s loyal clients that their retailer has done an exceptional job taking care of them.
Alexandra Lyons, manager at Blend Bar with Davidoff Cigars in Nashville, Tennessee
Davidoff strives to be a strong partner to retailers. How would you describe your business’s relationship with Davidoff? Tortorea: Our bond with Davidoff is extremely solid. The support provided through excellent marketing and the superb products that customers call in advance to reserve. It is a relationship of mutual success that we see in the constant communication with the team at the upper management and the quality of the local representative. Davidoff is never too busy to listen to us. They show us that they care.
Johnston: Blend currently has four stores: Houston, Nashville, Indianapolis and Pittsburgh. Davidoff provides excellent support for each store—training through Davidoff Academy, merchandising, consumer events and marketing/branding support. Three to four new Blend lounges are coming soon, and Davidoff is a critical partner to our success.
Cafagno: It’s the greatest business relationship I could ever imagine having with anybody. When Jim Young [Davidoff’s chief commercial officer and former president of Davidoff of Geneva USA] came in, the ideas he brought with him and the team he brought with him were amazing. There’s no other word to describe what they’ve done with the marketing and the whole way that the company operates. It’s just a complete transformation in terms of branding and appeal to all smokers, and you can’t say enough good about Jim Young, Lana Fraser [Davidoff’s head of marketing for the Americas], Dylan Austin, Zach Medwin [an area sales manager with Davidoff] and the rest of the team. These people are just very dedicated assets, both in personal and in business matters. It’s such a unique company to work with because they truly are there for you to grow. The amount of innovative tools that they’ve implemented over the years is just remarkable. I’ve been able to grow with them throughout this last year.
This story first appeared in the July/August 2020 issue of Tobacco Business magazine. Members of the tobacco industry are eligible for a complimentary subscription to our magazine. Click here for details.
– Story by Antoine Reid, senior editor and digital director for Tobacco Business Magazine. You can follow him on Instagram @editor.reid.
The Tobacconist of Greenwich has come up with a high end Cigar Club of the Month Membership. Each membership is available on a monthly basis. You can purchase 6, 10 or 15 cigar per month memberships. This is a great opportunity for you to try an array of different cigars. It is also the perfect opportunity for you to buy a wonderful Father’s Day, Birthday, or Great gift for anyone! Each Member will receive a CUSTOMIZED cigar box with their initials engraved on each box.
