Top Rated Cigars

When it comes to top-rated cigars, only the best in craftsmanship, flavor, and aging techniques earn high marks from aficionados and experts alike. From 95+ rated cigars to Cigar of the Year winners, these cigars deliver an exceptional smoking experience, blending premium aged tobaccos, flawless construction, and complex flavors. Whether you’re looking for luxury smokes, limited editions, or expert-recommended blends, the highest-rated cigars provide a truly memorable experience.

At The Tobacconist of Greenwich, we curate a collection of top-rated cigars, including award-winning brands like Davidoff, Padrón, Arturo Fuente, Fuente Fuente Opus X, and more. Whether you prefer a bold Nicaraguan masterpiece, a smooth Dominican classic, or a legendary Cuban blend from non-Cuban cigar makers, we have only the best. Shop now at The Tobacconist of Greenwich and experience the world’s finest cigars.

Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje Reserva Short Churchill

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $13.00 - $325.00

MSRP:

The Tatuaje Reserva Short Churchill is a 4 3/8" x 48 cigar that condenses the bold essence of the Tatuaje Reserva line into a shorter, fuller-flavored format. Blended by Pete Johnson and expertly handcrafted at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua,...
Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje RC233 Diademas

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $27.00 - $270.00

MSRP:

The Tatuaje RC233 Diademas is a commanding 9" x 55 diadema vitola—one of the largest and rarest cigars in Pete Johnson’s exclusive RC Series (Retro Cuban). Handcrafted at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua, the RC233 features an...
Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje RC184 Salomon

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $25.00 - $250.00

MSRP:

The Tatuaje RC184 Salomon is a 9 1/4" x 57 masterpiece—an ultra-premium, full-bodied salomon created for the true connoisseur. Part of Pete Johnson’s highly limited RC Series (Retro Cuban), the RC184 is handcrafted at the My Father Cigars...
Sold Out

Brick House Cigars

J.C. Newman Bricktoberfest 2025

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $120.00

The J.C. Newman Bricktoberfest 2025 from J.C. Newman is the annual limited-release pigtailed Churchill that honors the spirit of Oktoberfest. Rolled at the PENSA factory in Estelí, Nicaragua, it features an Ecuador Havana Rosado wrapper, with...
Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje Reserva A Uno

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $24.00 - $240.00

MSRP:

The Tatuaje Reserva A Uno is an extraordinary 9 1/4" x 47 Churchill Extra, created as a tribute to traditional Cuban gran vitolas. Blended by Pete Johnson and expertly crafted at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua, this full-bodied cigar is part...
Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje Havana Cazadores

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $12.00 - $300.00

MSRP:

The Tatuaje Havana Cazadores is a 6 3/8" x 43 Lonsdale-style cigar from Pete Johnson’s original Brown Label (Cabinet) series, designed to emulate the strength and structure of classic Cuban cigars. Handcrafted at the My Father Cigars factory in...
Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje K222

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $15.00 - $375.00

MSRP:

The Tatuaje K222 Reserva is a 5 7/8" x 52 toro created by Pete Johnson as a personal tribute, named in memory of his beloved dog, Kona, who passed away at 2:22 p.m. Crafted at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua, the K222 features a dark...
Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje Reserva SW

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $14.00 - $350.00

MSRP:

The Tatuaje Reserva SW is a 7" x 47 Churchill that delivers full-bodied flavor with elegance and complexity. Part of Pete Johnson’s celebrated Reserva line, this cigar is handcrafted at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua and features a dark...
Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje Reserva J21

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $13.00 - $325.00

MSRP:

The Tatuaje Reserva J21 is a 5" x 50 robusto that brings together the strength of Nicaraguan tobacco and the sweetness of a Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper in a refined, Cuban-inspired format. Blended by Pete Johnson and rolled at the My Father Cigars...
Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje Gran Cojonu Miami Reserva

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $16.00 - $192.00

MSRP:

The Tatuaje Gran Cojonu is a commanding 6 1/2" x 60 full-bodied gordo designed for those who crave strength, richness, and a long, luxurious smoking experience. Blended by Pete Johnson and handcrafted at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua, this...
Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje Cojonu 2009 Miami Reserva

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $15.00 - $375.00

MSRP:

The Tatuaje Cojonu 2009 is a 6 3/4" x 48 torpedo that delivers the hallmark strength and richness of Pete Johnson’s acclaimed Cojonu series. Handcrafted at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua, this full-bodied cigar features an Ecuadorian...
Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje Cojonu 2006 Miami Reserva

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $15.00 - $375.00

MSRP:

The Tatuaje Cojonu 2006 is a 5 1/2" x 52 torpedo that continues the legacy of Pete Johnson’s powerhouse Cojonu series—known for its bold, full-bodied blends and uncompromising flavor. Rolled at the esteemed My Father Cigars factory in...