Top Rated Cigars

When it comes to top-rated cigars, only the best in craftsmanship, flavor, and aging techniques earn high marks from aficionados and experts alike. From 95+ rated cigars to Cigar of the Year winners, these cigars deliver an exceptional smoking experience, blending premium aged tobaccos, flawless construction, and complex flavors. Whether you’re looking for luxury smokes, limited editions, or expert-recommended blends, the highest-rated cigars provide a truly memorable experience.

At The Tobacconist of Greenwich, we curate a collection of top-rated cigars, including award-winning brands like Davidoff, Padrón, Arturo Fuente, Fuente Fuente Opus X, and more. Whether you prefer a bold Nicaraguan masterpiece, a smooth Dominican classic, or a legendary Cuban blend from non-Cuban cigar makers, we have only the best. Shop now at The Tobacconist of Greenwich and experience the world’s finest cigars.

Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje Surrogates Satin Glove 654

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $9.50 - $190.00

MSRP:

The Tatuaje Surrogates Satin Glove 654 is a 6" x 54 toro grande that delivers bold flavor with an unexpectedly smooth touch—living up to its name. Crafted at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua and blended by Pete Johnson, this full-bodied...
Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje Surrogates Tramp Stamp

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $8.50 - $170.00

MSRP:

The Tatuaje Surrogates Tramp Stamp is a 5 1/4" x 48 robusto that brings attitude, strength, and complexity in one full-bodied package. Blended by Pete Johnson and rolled at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua, this fan-favorite features a dark...
Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje Surrogates Skull Breaker

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $9.50 - $190.00

MSRP:

The Tatuaje Surrogates Skull Breaker is a 5 1/4" x 52 robusto that delivers a knockout punch of bold flavor and complexity. Blended by Pete Johnson and expertly crafted at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua, this full-bodied cigar features a dark,...
Weller by Cohiba Limited Edition

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $299.90

The Weller by Cohiba Limited Edition represents a groundbreaking collaboration between two icons of luxury craftsmanship: Cohiba and Weller Bourbon. This exclusive release unites the artistry of premium cigar blending with the heritage of one of...
Sold Out

Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje The Mummy Redux #5

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $169.00

Tatuaje The Mummy Redux #5 returns as part of Tatuaje’s celebrated Monster Series Redux program, bringing back one of the most iconic releases with updated presentation and reverence to its roots. This upcoming edition will be made by My Father...
Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje Surrogates Cracker Crumbs

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $17.50 - $175.00

MSRP:

The Tatuaje Surrogates Cracker Crumbs is a 4 1/2" x 38 petite corona that packs serious flavor into a quick, bold smoke. Crafted at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua, this small-format cigar features an Ecuadorian Habano Oscuro wrapper over a...
Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje Surrogates Crystal Baller

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $9.50 - $190.00

MSRP:

The Tatuaje Surrogates Crystal Baller is a 5 3/4" x 56 gran toro that blends strength, complexity, and refinement in true boutique style. Blended by Pete Johnson and handcrafted at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua, this full-bodied cigar...
Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje Surrogates Bone Crusher

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $9.50 - $190.00

MSRP:

The Tatuaje Surrogates Bone Crusher is a 5 1/4" x 55 full-bodied robusto designed for those who crave raw power and intense flavor. Blended by Pete Johnson and handcrafted at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua, this potent cigar features a thick...
Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje Surrogates Animal Cracker

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $11.00 - $220.00

MSRP:

The Tatuaje Surrogates Animal Cracker is a 6" x 60 full-bodied Nicaraguan cigar that lives up to its name—bold, untamed, and packed with flavor. Blended by Pete Johnson and produced at the renowned My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua, this...
Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje Surrogates Animal Cracker 550

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $9.00 - $180.00

MSRP:

The Tatuaje Surrogates Animal Cracker 550 is a 5" x 50 robusto-sized cigar that condenses all the raw power of the original Animal Cracker into a shorter, punchier format. Blended by Pete Johnson and rolled at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua,...
Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje Surrogates 7th Sam

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $11.00 - $220.00

MSRP:

The Tatuaje Surrogates 7th Sam is a 6 3/4" x 52 perfecto that brings power, complexity, and boutique flair to the forefront. Blended by Pete Johnson and crafted at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua, this full-bodied cigar features a rich...
Tatuaje Cigars

Tatuaje L'Atelier Selection Speciale 56

MSRP:

Was:

Now: $11.00 - $165.00

MSRP:

The Tatuaje L'Atelier Selection Spéciale 56 is a 6 1/2" x 56 toro grande that delivers deep flavor and complex body in a bold, slow-burning format. Handcrafted at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua, this full-bodied cigar features a...