Top Rated Cigars

When it comes to top-rated cigars, only the best in craftsmanship, flavor, and aging techniques earn high marks from aficionados and experts alike. From 95+ rated cigars to Cigar of the Year winners, these cigars deliver an exceptional smoking experience, blending premium aged tobaccos, flawless construction, and complex flavors. Whether you’re looking for luxury smokes, limited editions, or expert-recommended blends, the highest-rated cigars provide a truly memorable experience.

At The Tobacconist of Greenwich, we curate a collection of top-rated cigars, including award-winning brands like Davidoff, Padrón, Arturo Fuente, Fuente Fuente Opus X, and more. Whether you prefer a bold Nicaraguan masterpiece, a smooth Dominican classic, or a legendary Cuban blend from non-Cuban cigar makers, we have only the best. Shop now at The Tobacconist of Greenwich and experience the world’s finest cigars.

Read More
Filter results
  • Red Meat Lovers Filet Mignon Box Open Red Meat Lovers Filet Mignon Single Cigar

    Red Meat Lovers Cigars

    Red Meat Lovers Filet Mignon

    $15.65 - $156.50

    The Red Meat Lovers Filet Mignon is a 5 x 54 cigar designed for those who crave full-bodied, savory complexity in a perfectly balanced size. Wrapped in a dark Connecticut Broadleaf, this cigar is packed with aged Nicaraguan long-fillers, delivering deep...

  • Red Meat Lovers Beefstick Box Open Red Meat Lovers Beefstick Single Cigar

    Red Meat Lovers Cigars

    Red Meat Lovers Beefstick

    $16.25 - $162.50

    The Red Meat Lovers Beefstick is a cigar crafted for those who crave bold, meaty flavors with deep complexity. This 4 ½ x 50 robusto-sized smoke features a dark Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper, which enhances its rich, smoky, and savory profile...

  • Sold Out
    Metapa Nicaragua Toro Box Open Metapa Nicaragua Toro Single Cigar

    Metapa Cigars

    Foundation Metapa Nicaragua Toro

    $16.50 - $165.00

    The Foundation Metapa Maduro Toro (6" x 52) is a medium-to-full-bodied cigar crafted to honor Nicaragua's rich cultural heritage, specifically paying tribute to the renowned poet Rubén Darío and his birthplace, Metapa. This box-pressed...

  • Sold Out
    Foundation Metapa Nicaragua Robusto Box Open Foundation Metapa Nicaragua Robusto Single Cigar

    Metapa Cigars

    Foundation Metapa Nicaragua Robusto

    $15.50 - $155.00

    The Foundation Metapa Nicaragua Robusto (5" x 50) is a medium-to-full-bodied cigar that pays homage to Nicaragua's rich cultural heritage, specifically honoring the renowned poet Rubén Darío and his birthplace, Metapa. This box-pressed...

  • Sold Out
    Foundation Metapa Nicaragua Double Corona Box Open Foundation Metapa Nicaragua Double Corona Single Cigar

    Metapa Cigars

    Foundation Metapa Nicaragua Double Corona

    $18.00 - $180.00

    The Foundation Metapa Nicaragua Double Corona (7" x 54) is a medium-to-full-bodied cigar that pays tribute to Nicaragua's rich cultural heritage, specifically honoring the renowned poet Rubén Darío and his birthplace, Metapa. This...

  • Sold Out
    Foundation Metapa Nicaragua Corona Gorda Box Open Foundation Metapa Nicaragua Corona Gorda Single Cigar

    Metapa Cigars

    Foundation Metapa Nicaragua Corona Gorda

    $14.50 - $145.00

    The Foundation Metapa Nicaragua Corona Gorda (5 1/2" x 48) is a medium-to-full-bodied cigar that pays tribute to Nicaragua's rich cultural heritage, specifically honoring the renowned poet Rubén Darío and his birthplace, Metapa. This...

  • Sold Out
    Rare Character Opus Xodus 10-Year Bourbon Whiskey Bottle Front Rare Character Opus Xodus 10-Year Bourbon Whiskey Bottle Back

    Arturo Fuente Cigars

    Rare Character Opus Xodus 10-Year Bourbon Whiskey

    $661.00

    The Rare Character Opus Xodus 10-Year Bourbon Whiskey is a distinguished spirit crafted in collaboration with Carlito Fuente Jr., labeled as "Carlito Fuente Jr's Special Reserve." This 10-year-old bourbon is meticulously produced from hand-selected...

  • Sin Compromiso Seleccion No 7 Parejo Box Open Sin Compromiso Seleccion No 7 Parejo Single Cigar

    Sin Compromiso Cigars

    Sin Compromiso Seleccion No 7 Parejo

    $20.75 - $269.70

    The Sin Compromiso Selección No. 7 Parejo is a premium, full-bodied cigar meticulously crafted by master blender Steve Saka of Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust. Measuring 7 x 56, this Double Corona-sized vitola features a dark and oily Mexican San...

  • Sin Compromiso Seleccion No 5 Parejo Box Open Sin Compromiso Seleccion No 5 Parejo Single Cigar

    Sin Compromiso Cigars

    Sin Compromiso Seleccion No 5 Parejo

    $19.75 - $256.76

    The Sin Compromiso Selección No. 5 Parejo is a premium, full-bodied cigar meticulously crafted by master blender Steve Saka of Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust. Measuring 6 x 54, this Toro-sized vitola features a dark and oily Mexican San...

  • Sin Compromiso Seleccion No 4 Parejo Box Open Sin Compromiso Seleccion No 4 Parejo Single Cigar

    Sin Compromiso Cigars

    Sin Compromiso Seleccion No 4 Parejo

    $18.95 - $246.36

    The Sin Compromiso Selección No. 4 Parejo is a luxuriously rich and complex cigar, crafted with precision by Steve Saka of Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust. This 6 x 52 parejo features a dark Mexican San Andrés Negro wrapper, aged to...

  • Sin Compromiso Seleccion No 2 Torpedo Box Open Sin Compromiso Seleccion No 2 Torpedo Single Cigar

    Sin Compromiso Cigars

    Sin Compromiso Seleccion No 2 Torpedo

    $20.45 - $265.80

    The Sin Compromiso Selección No. 2 Torpedo is a meticulously crafted 6 x 52 cigar that delivers a bold yet refined smoking experience. Wrapped in a Mexican San Andrés Negro leaf, this full-bodied masterpiece offers deep notes of dark...

  • Sin Compromiso Seleccion "Varita Magica" Box Open Sin Compromiso Seleccion "Varita Magica" Single Cigar

    Sin Compromiso Cigars

    Sin Compromiso Seleccion "Varita Magica"

    $17.95 - $233.35

    The Sin Compromiso Selección "Varita Magica" is a 6 ¼ x 46 cigar that combines refinement and complexity in a perfectly balanced vitola. Featuring a dark Mexican San Andrés Negro wrapper, this full-bodied cigar delivers rich notes of...