Top Rated Cigars

When it comes to top-rated cigars, only the best in craftsmanship, flavor, and aging techniques earn high marks from aficionados and experts alike. From 95+ rated cigars to Cigar of the Year winners, these cigars deliver an exceptional smoking experience, blending premium aged tobaccos, flawless construction, and complex flavors. Whether you’re looking for luxury smokes, limited editions, or expert-recommended blends, the highest-rated cigars provide a truly memorable experience.

At The Tobacconist of Greenwich, we curate a collection of top-rated cigars, including award-winning brands like Davidoff, Padrón, Arturo Fuente, Fuente Fuente Opus X, and more. Whether you prefer a bold Nicaraguan masterpiece, a smooth Dominican classic, or a legendary Cuban blend from non-Cuban cigar makers, we have only the best. Shop now at The Tobacconist of Greenwich and experience the world’s finest cigars.

Read More
  • Tatuaje Cojonu 2003 Miami Reserva Box Open Tatuaje Cojonu 2003 Miami Reserva Single Cigar

    Tatuaje Cigars

    Tatuaje Cojonu 2003 Miami Reserva

    $15.00 - $375.00

    The Tatuaje Cojonu 2003 is a 6 1/2" x 52 toro that exemplifies bold strength, deep flavor, and the refined craftsmanship that defines Pete Johnson’s celebrated Cojonu series. Handcrafted at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua, this...

  • Tatuaje Tainos Broadleaf Box Open Tatuaje Tainos Broadleaf Single Cigar

    Tatuaje Cigars

    Tatuaje Tainos Broadleaf

    $14.00 - $350.00

    The Tatuaje Tainos is a 7 5/8" x 49 Churchill that showcases the Cuban roots of the Tatuaje Cabinet Series, combining traditional vitola dimensions with modern Nicaraguan depth. Blended by Pete Johnson and rolled at the renowned My Father Cigars factory,...

  • Tatuaje Unicos Broadleaf Box Open Tatuaje Unicos Broadleaf Single Cigar

    Tatuaje Cigars

    Tatuaje Unicos Broadleaf

    $13.00 - $325.00

    The Tatuaje Unicos is a 6 1/8" x 52 torpedo that perfectly marries Cuban tradition with Nicaraguan strength and character. Part of Pete Johnson’s original Tatuaje Cabinet Series (Brown Label), this full-bodied cigar is handcrafted at the My Father...

  • Tatuaje Especiales Broadleaf Box Open Tatuaje Especiales Broadleaf Single Cigar

    Tatuaje Cigars

    Tatuaje Especiales Broadleaf

    $12.00 - $300.00

    The Tatuaje Especiales is a 7 1/2" x 38 Lancero that showcases the finesse and balance of traditional Cuban vitolas with the bold richness of Nicaraguan tobacco. Part of the original Tatuaje Cabinet Series, this long and slender cigar is blended by Pete...

  • Tatuaje Regios Broadleaf Box Open Tatuaje Regios Broadleaf Single Cigar

    Tatuaje Cigars

    Tatuaje Regios Broadleaf

    $12.00 - $300.00

    The Tatuaje Regios is a 5 1/2" x 50 robusto that exemplifies the Cuban tradition with a modern Nicaraguan twist. Blended by Pete Johnson and rolled at the My Father Cigars factory, this medium to full-bodied cigar is part of the original brown label...

  • Tatuaje Noellas Broadleaf Box Open Tatuaje Noellas Broadleaf Single Cigar

    Tatuaje Cigars

    Tatuaje Noellas Broadleaf

    $10.00 - $250.00

    The Tatuaje Noellas is a 5 1/8" x 42 traditional corona that captures the essence of old-world Cuban craftsmanship in a medium to full-bodied Nicaraguan cigar. Blended by Pete Johnson and crafted at the famed El Rey de los Habanos factory in Miami, this...

  • Tatuaje El Suelo Vuelo Box Open Tatuaje El Suelo Vuelo Single Cigar

    Tatuaje Cigars

    Tatuaje El Suelo Vuelo

    $17.50 - $175.00

    The El Suelo Vuelo is a 4 1/2" x 38 petite corona that delivers bold, earthy flavor at an excellent everyday value. Blended by Pete Johnson and crafted at the renowned My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua, this medium-full bodied cigar features a dark...

  • Tatuaje La Mission 2009 Box Open Tatuaje La Mission 2009 Single Cigar

    Tatuaje Cigars

    Tatuaje La Mission 2009

    $11.00 - $198.00

    The La Mission L'Atelier 2009 is a 6 1/2" x 56 Churchill that combines powerful Nicaraguan character with elegant Old World sophistication. Crafted at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua and blended by Pete Johnson, this medium-full bodied cigar...

  • Tatuaje La Mission 1989 Box Open Tatuaje La Mission 1989 Single Cigar

    Tatuaje Cigars

    Tatuaje La Mission 1989

    $10.00 - $180.00

    The La Mission L'Atelier 1989 is a 5 5/8" x 54 toro that offers a luxurious medium-full bodied smoking experience with French wine-inspired sophistication. Blended by Pete Johnson and handcrafted at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua, this...

  • Tatuaje La Mission 1959 Box Open Tatuaje La Mission 1959 Single Cigar

    Tatuaje Cigars

    Tatuaje La Mission 1959

    $9.00 - $162.00

    The La Mission L'Atelier 1959 is a 4 3/4" x 52 robusto that delivers bold, elegant flavor inspired by the great wine estates of France. Blended by Pete Johnson and crafted at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua, this medium-full bodied cigar...

  • Tatuaje Surrogates Cracker Crumbs Cabinet Box Open Tatuaje Surrogates Cracker Crumbs Cabinet Single Cigar

    Tatuaje Cigars

    Tatuaje Surrogates Cracker Crumbs Cabinet

    $17.50 - $175.00

    The Tatuaje Surrogates Cracker Crumbs Cabinet offers a curated 5-pack of 4 1/2" x 38 petite coronas—perfect for cigar lovers who enjoy big flavor in a small format. Crafted at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua, these full-bodied cigars...

  • Tatuaje Surrogates Eight Baller Box Closed Tatuaje Surrogates Eight Baller Single Cigar

    Tatuaje Cigars

    Tatuaje Surrogates Eight Baller

    $10.00 - $200.00

    The Tatuaje Surrogates Eight Baller is a commanding 5 3/4" x 56 full-bodied gordo designed for those who enjoy intensity and complexity in a long, bold format. Blended by Pete Johnson and handmade at the My Father Cigars factory in Nicaragua, this...